Ayudante de cocina de uniforme blanco limpia una encimera en una cocina de hotel vacía

ERTE in Spain: What It Means for Your Hours, Pay and Rights

Published

“We are cutting your working hours in half for four months.” When a company announces something like this, the first thing many people feel is fear. Am I going to be fired? How much will I earn? What happens to my contract?

Take a breath: an ERTE in Spain is not a dismissal. It is a temporary measure that allows the company to reduce working hours or suspend employment contracts for a period of time, for specific reasons and following a set procedure. Your contract is still alive. In this article we explain what an ERTE means for your working hours, your pay and your rights, what limits the company has while it lasts and how to challenge it if those limits are not respected. We do it through the case of Wilmer, a kitchen assistant at a hotel in Salou. If you are in an ERTE right now and have questions, write to Fernanda Vargas, employment lawyer in Madrid, on WhatsApp or book an appointment on Calendly.

“We Are Cutting Your Hours in Half”: the ERTE at Wilmer’s Hotel

Wilmer is 37. He is from El Salvador, holds a residence and work authorization and works as a kitchen assistant at a hotel in Salou with 70 employees.

In October, once the summer is over, bookings drop. Management announces an ERTE: for four months, the kitchen and housekeeping staff will work half their usual hours, a 50% reduction.

The hotel has no workers’ representatives. So the staff elect a committee of three people to negotiate with management. After twelve days of consultations, there is no agreement. Even so, the company applies the reduction.

Wilmer adjusts as best he can. But in November he notices two things that do not add up. The hotel has brought in two kitchen assistants through an ETT (a temporary employment agency) for the weekends. And he is being asked to work overtime on Saturdays, paid separately.

Can the hotel do all this? What can Wilmer do? Let’s take it step by step. (Wilmer is an example case and his figures are illustrative.)

What an ERTE Is and How It Differs from a Dismissal

ERTE stands for “expediente de regulación temporal de empleo”, a temporary layoff or short-time work scheme. The key word is temporary. It is governed by article 47 of the Workers’ Statute (Estatuto de los Trabajadores), which begins like this:

“The company may temporarily reduce the working hours of employees or temporarily suspend employment contracts, for economic, technical, organizational or production reasons of a temporary nature, in accordance with the provisions of this article and the procedure established by regulation.”

Put simply, for a period of time the company can do one of these two things:

  • Reduce working hours: you work fewer hours. This is what happens to Wilmer, who now works half his usual hours.
  • Suspend the contract: you stop working for a period, but the contract is not terminated.

In both cases, your contract is not terminated. When the ERTE ends, you go back to your previous situation.

That is the big difference from a collective dismissal, the well-known ERE (article 51 of the Workers’ Statute): in an ERE the contracts are terminated; in an ERTE they are kept.

Besides the ERTE for economic, technical, organizational or production reasons, there is the ERTE for temporary force majeure, designed for situations beyond the company’s control that prevent it from operating normally. We describe an example in our article on wildfires in Spain and employment rights. There is also the RED Mechanism (article 47 bis), which is a different tool. Here we focus on the “ordinary” ERTE, the one Wilmer is facing.

One more useful clarification: an ERTE is also not the same as the inactive periods of a permanent seasonal contract (fijo discontinuo), which follow their own rules. If that is your situation, we explain it in our guide to permanent seasonal contracts: call-ups, unemployment benefit and rights.

The Grounds: Economic, Technical, Organizational, Production and Force Majeure

An ERTE cannot be carried out for no reason. It needs a ground, and that ground has to be temporary: a passing problem, not a permanent one. These are the grounds, explained with simple examples:

  • Economic reasons: the company is going through a negative economic situation. For example, it has losses, or expects to have them, or its income or sales fall persistently: the law refers to two consecutive quarters in which income or sales are lower than in the same quarter of the previous year.
  • Technical reasons: there are changes in the means or instruments of production, that is, in the tools used to do the work (art. 47.2 in connection with art. 51.1 of the Statute). For example, a factory that replaces its machinery.
  • Organizational reasons: there are changes in the staff’s work systems and methods or in the way production is organized (art. 47.2 in connection with art. 51.1 of the Statute). For example, a new way of allocating shifts and tasks.
  • Production reasons: there are changes in the demand for the products or services the company sells. In other words: customers buy or book less.
  • Temporary force majeure: an event beyond the company’s control prevents it from operating normally for a time. It has its own procedure (art. 47.5 of the Statute) and we only mention it here.

In Wilmer’s case, the ground the hotel relies on is production reasons: after the summer there are fewer bookings, that is, less demand for rooms and meals. For the ERTE to be justified, that drop has to be real and temporary.

How It Must Be Processed: Consultation Period and Representative Committee

The company cannot apply an ERTE overnight. The procedure begins with a notification to the labor authority and, at the same time, the opening of a consultation period with the employees’ legal representatives.

What is the consultation period? It is a negotiation stage: the company and the staff representatives discuss the grounds and the measure and try to reach an agreement. The law sets a maximum length:

  • Fifteen days at most, as a general rule.
  • Seven days at most, in companies with fewer than fifty employees.

Wilmer’s hotel has 70 employees, so its maximum is fifteen days. The consultations lasted twelve: within the limit.

If There Are No Representatives: the Representative Committee

Many small and medium-sized companies have no workers’ representatives. That does not prevent an ERTE, but someone has to negotiate on behalf of the staff. For this, a representative committee is formed: a small group of people who talk to the company on behalf of everyone.

That committee must be set up before the consultation period opens, within a maximum of five days from when the company announces its intention to start the procedure. At Wilmer’s hotel, the staff elected a committee of three people.

With and Without an Agreement

Whether or not there is an agreement makes a big difference:

  • With an agreement: the grounds are presumed to exist. That agreement can only be challenged before the Labor Court (Juzgado de lo Social) if there was fraud, deceit, coercion or abuse of rights. In plain words: if it was obtained through deception, pressure or bad faith.
  • Without an agreement: the company can still apply the measure. But each employee can challenge it individually. And if the ERTE affects a number of people equal to or above the collective dismissal thresholds, a collective dispute is also possible.

A practical tip: ask the company or the committee for the ERTE notification, which must state the ground, the duration, the percentage of the reduction and the people affected. It is the basis for knowing whether the measure is being applied to you correctly.

How Much Your Hours Can Be Reduced: from 10% to 70%

If your ERTE reduces your working hours, like Wilmer’s, there are clear limits. Article 47.7.a says:

“The reduction in working hours may be between ten and seventy percent and be calculated on the basis of daily, weekly, monthly or annual working hours.”

In other words: the company can reduce your hours by at least 10% and at most 70%. And that reduction can be calculated on your daily, weekly, monthly or annual working hours. The 50% at Wilmer’s hotel is within that range.

The same provision adds that, whenever feasible, reducing working hours takes priority over suspending contracts. The idea is that you keep working, even if less, instead of stopping work altogether.

And your pay? If you work fewer hours, the salary the company pays you will normally go down. That is why unemployment benefit, which we cover a little further below, is so important.

What the Company Cannot Do During the ERTE

Let’s go back to November at the hotel. Wilmer is working half his hours because of the ERTE. But the hotel brings in two kitchen assistants from an ETT for the weekends and asks him to work overtime on Saturdays. Does that make sense? If there is so little work that the company reduces hours, it cannot at the same time add overtime or bring in outside people to do the same work. That is exactly what the law prohibits:

“During the period in which the procedure applies, no overtime may be worked, no new outsourcing of activity may be established and no new employment contracts may be entered into.”

While the ERTE lasts, the company is bound by three prohibitions:

  • No overtime. It does not matter if they pay you separately for it.
  • No new outsourcing: handing over to another company an activity that was not outsourced before.
  • No new employment contracts.

There is only one exception, for new hires and outsourcing: when the people affected by the ERTE at that workplace cannot perform those functions because of training, qualifications or other objective and justified reasons. Even then, the company must first inform the employees’ legal representatives. For example, if the hotel needed a profile with very specific training that nobody among the affected staff has.

That is not Wilmer’s case. The two assistants who arrive through the ETT do the same work he can do. And the Saturday overtime is prohibited while the ERTE lasts. Wilmer can refuse to work it.

What you can do if something similar happens to you:

  • Write things down and keep evidence: what overtime you are asked to work, on which days, and which new people have joined and when.
  • Report it in writing to the company and to the representatives (or the committee).
  • File a complaint with the Labor Inspectorate (Inspección de Trabajo) if the breach continues.

Unemployment Benefit During the ERTE: the Essentials

During an ERTE you can access unemployment benefit (prestación por desempleo) under the terms set by Social Security (Seguridad Social) rules. It is managed by SEPE, the public employment service.

The amounts and requirements depend on those rules and on your personal situation, which is why we do not give figures here. What matters is that you know that during the ERTE you can access unemployment benefit under the terms of the Social Security rules, and that you check your case with SEPE or with Fernanda Vargas if you have questions.

How to Challenge an ERTE That Is Not Justified

If you believe the ground for the ERTE does not exist, or is not temporary, you can challenge it. Article 47.3 says so: the employee can bring a claim before the labor courts, that is, before the Labor Court (Juzgado de lo Social), which will declare the measure justified or unjustified.

If the court declares it unjustified:

  • It orders the immediate resumption of the contract on its previous terms.
  • The company must pay you the wages you did not receive until that resumption or, where applicable, the difference compared with what you received as unemployment benefit during that time.

Remember what we saw earlier: if the consultation period ended with an agreement, the grounds are presumed to exist and it can only be challenged for fraud, deceit, coercion or abuse of rights. If it ended without an agreement, as at Wilmer’s hotel, you can challenge the measure individually on the basis that the ground does not exist.

There is a deadline to challenge it, so do not wait: get your case checked as soon as possible. Fernanda Vargas, employment lawyer in Madrid, can review your ERTE and help you bring a claim; you can see how she works on her page on employment law advice.

How Wilmer’s Case Is Resolved

Let’s put it all together.

The ERTE itself may be valid. The hotel can carry out an ERTE reducing working hours for production reasons if the drop in bookings is real and temporary. And the procedure seems to have been followed: there was a representative committee and the consultation period lasted twelve days, within the fifteen-day maximum.

The lack of agreement does not stop it. Even without an agreement, the company can apply the measure. If Wilmer believes the ground does not exist, he can challenge it before the Labor Court.

What the hotel cannot do. While the ERTE lasts, it cannot ask Wilmer to work overtime or hire other people, directly or through an ETT, to do the same work he can do.

What Wilmer does. He can report it in writing to the company and the committee, refuse the overtime and file a complaint with the Labor Inspectorate. And if the court declares the measure unjustified, his full working hours are restored and the company pays him the difference.

Summary: What the Company Can and Cannot Do

What the company can doWhat it cannot do during the ERTE
Temporarily reduce working hours or suspend contracts for economic, technical, organizational or production reasons of a temporary natureCarry out an ERTE without a real ground or for a problem that is not temporary
Reduce working hours by between 10% and 70%Apply the ERTE without notifying the labor authority or opening the consultation period
Apply the measure even if the consultation period ends without agreementAsk you to work overtime, even if paid separately
Hire or outsource only if the affected people cannot perform those functions because of training, qualifications or other objective and justified reasons, informing the representatives firstHire other people, directly or through an ETT, or outsource activity, for work you can do

Frequently Asked Questions

Is an ERTE the Same as a Dismissal?

No. In an ERTE your contract is not terminated: the company reduces your working hours or suspends your contract for a time, and when the ERTE ends you go back to your previous situation. In a collective dismissal (ERE), on the other hand, the contracts are terminated.

How Much Can My Hours Be Reduced in an ERTE?

Between 10% and 70%, calculated on daily, weekly, monthly or annual working hours. In addition, whenever feasible, the law gives priority to reducing working hours over suspending the contract.

Can I Be Asked to Work Overtime During an ERTE?

No. While the ERTE lasts, the law prohibits overtime, even if it is paid separately. If you are asked to work it, you can refuse, report it in writing to the company and the representatives, and file a complaint with the Labor Inspectorate.

They Have Hired New People During the ERTE: Is That Legal?

As a general rule, no. During the ERTE there can be no new hires or new outsourcing, and that includes using an ETT to do your same work. The only exception is when the affected people cannot perform those functions because of training, qualifications or other objective and justified reasons, and the company must first inform the workers’ representatives. If they hire someone for work you can do, the exception does not apply.

How Can I Challenge an ERTE I Believe Is Not Justified?

You can challenge the measure before the Labor Court. If the consultation period ended with an agreement, the grounds are presumed to exist and it can only be challenged for fraud, deceit, coercion or abuse of rights; if it ended without an agreement, you can challenge the measure individually on the basis that the ground does not exist (art. 47.3 of the Statute). If the court declares it unjustified, your contract is resumed and the company pays you the wages you did not receive or the difference compared with unemployment benefit. There is a deadline to bring a claim, so seek advice as soon as possible.

If you are in an ERTE and something does not add up, do not let it slide: write to Fernanda Vargas, employment lawyer in Madrid, on WhatsApp or book an appointment on Calendly to have your case reviewed.

How we can help

Does this affect you? Fernanda Vargas reviews your case and explains your options. More about Employment lawyer in Madrid.