Dos compañeras de oficina, una embarazada, revisan juntas carpetas y una pantalla de ordenador

Substitution Contract in Spain: When It Ends and Your Rights

Published

Lorena is 32, Peruvian, holds a residence and work authorization and works as an administrative assistant at a services company in Córdoba. In January she signed a substitution contract to cover her coworker Cristina’s birth leave. Everything went well: she learned the job, Cristina came back in June and the contract ended. But the company immediately offered her a second contract, also “for substitution,” this time to cover the position of a coworker who had retired “while someone permanent is being selected.” Five months have gone by, nobody has opened any selection process and Lorena is still sitting at that desk, with no idea when her job will end.

If you are in a similar situation, this article is for you. We will look at what a substitution contract is in Spain, when it ends, what rights you have while it lasts and when you can claim to be recognized as a permanent employee. If you would rather have someone review your contract directly, write to Fernanda Vargas, employment lawyer in Madrid, on WhatsApp or book an appointment on Calendly.

“You Stay Until We Find Someone”: Lorena’s Two Contracts

Lorena’s story has two parts, and each one corresponds to a different use of the same contract.

The first contract was to replace Cristina during her birth leave. The document stated Cristina’s name and the reason (the birth leave), and Lorena started working ten days before Cristina left, so that Cristina could explain the tasks, the clients and the software. When Cristina returned in June, Lorena’s contract ended.

The second contract is different. It no longer replaces a specific person who is going to come back: it covers a position that has become free, that of a retired coworker. The company told her: “you stay until we find someone.” But it has not looked for anyone. It has been like this for five months.

There is a third detail that has bothered Lorena from the start: her payslip does not include the collective agreement bonus that her coworkers in the same position receive. “Since I’m the substitute, I suppose that’s normal,” she thought. It is not, and we will see why below.

Before solving Lorena’s case, you need to understand how this contract works.

What Is a Substitution Contract (the Former Interim Contract)

The substitution contract (contrato de sustitución) is a temporary contract (the law calls it a fixed-term contract, “de duración determinada”) used to fill the gap left by another worker. It is what used to be called the interim contract (contrato de interinidad). Its name and its rules changed with the labor reform approved by Royal Decree-Law 32/2021, which amended Article 15 of the Workers’ Statute (Estatuto de los Trabajadores).

Since that reform, the law only allows two types of temporary contract: the contract due to production circumstances (for peaks of work or occasional situations) and the substitution contract. They should not be confused. The first responds to the company having more work than usual; the second responds to someone being absent, or to a position waiting to be filled by a permanent employee. In this article we only discuss the second.

The substitution contract has three uses, each with its own rules:

  • Replacing a worker who has the right to have their job held for them (for example, during birth leave, temporary incapacity or a leave of absence with job protection).
  • Covering the hours that another worker has reduced, when that reduction has a legal or collective agreement basis.
  • Temporarily covering a vacant position while a selection or promotion process is carried out to fill it with a permanent contract.

What they have in common is that their length does not depend on a date picked at random, but on the reason: the contract lasts as long as the reason that justifies it. That is why it is so important for that reason to be written in the contract and to still exist.

A word of warning: here we are talking about private companies. Interim staff in the public administration have their own rules, which this article does not cover.

Key Requirement: Name of the Replaced Worker and the Reason

Let’s go back to Lorena’s first contract. Why was it correct? Because it said two things: who she was replacing (Cristina) and why (her birth leave). That is exactly what Article 15.3 of the Workers’ Statute requires:

Fixed-term contracts may be entered into to replace a worker with the right to have their job held for them, provided that the contract specifies the name of the replaced worker and the reason for the substitution. In that case, the provision of services may begin before the absence of the replaced worker occurs, with both performing the duties together for the time strictly necessary to ensure the proper performance of the job and, at most, for fifteen days.

Let’s take it step by step, in plain words.

What “the Right to Have Your Job Held” Means

Having the right to have your job held (reserva de puesto de trabajo) means that the person who is absent is guaranteed to return to their position when the absence ends. The company cannot give it permanently to someone else: it has to keep it for them. This is what happens, for example, during birth leave, temporary incapacity (sick leave) or a leave of absence with job protection. If you want to know what types of leave of absence exist and in which ones the job is held, you can read our guide on leave of absence in Spain, its types and returning to work.

What “Replaced Worker” Means

The replaced worker (persona sustituida) is the person who is absent and whose position you cover. In Lorena’s case, Cristina. The law requires their name to appear in the contract, together with the reason for the substitution. It is not enough to write “to replace staff on leave” or “due to business needs”: it must be clear whom you are covering and why.

Why does this matter so much? Because if the contract does not say whom you replace or why, there is no way to know when it ends, and the law does not allow a temporary contract without a clear reason. As we will see, if these rules are not met, the person hired becomes a permanent employee.

The Fifteen-Day Handover

Lorena started ten days before Cristina left. During those days they worked together: Cristina showed her the files, introduced her to the clients and explained how things worked. This is what the law describes as performing “the duties together.”

The law allows it, but with two limits:

  • Only for the time strictly necessary for the substitute to be able to do the job properly.
  • At most, fifteen days.

Lorena was there for ten days, so her handover complied with the law. If the company hires you “to replace” someone who is not leaving for another two months, and in the meantime you work normally, that period is no longer a handover: it is something else, and it is worth having it reviewed.

Covering Reduced Working Hours

The second use of the substitution contract is less well known. Imagine that one of Lorena’s coworkers reduces her working hours to look after her child and starts working only in the mornings. The company can hire another person to cover the afternoons she no longer works.

Article 15.3 allows this as follows: the substitution contract may be entered into “to cover the reduced working hours of another worker, when that reduction is based on grounds established by law or regulated in the collective agreement.” And, once again, the contract must state the name of the replaced worker and the reason for the substitution.

In practice, this means two things:

  • The reduction of working hours must have a basis in the law or in the collective agreement (convenio colectivo). Just any reorganization of the company’s schedules is not enough.
  • Your contract must identify the person whose hours you are covering and the reason for their reduction.

And, as in the previous case, the length is tied to the reason: your contract lasts as long as the reduction of working hours you cover.

Covering a Vacancy During Selection: Three Months at Most

We come to Lorena’s second contract, the one that causes problems. Here there is nobody who is going to come back. The position is empty because its holder has retired, and the company says it is going to look for someone permanent.

The law allows the substitution contract to be used to cover that vacancy in the meantime, but with a very clear limit. Article 15.3 says so: this contract may be used “for the temporary coverage of a position during the selection or promotion process for its permanent coverage through a permanent contract, without its length in this case exceeding three months, or the shorter period set in the collective agreement, nor may a new contract with the same purpose be entered into once that maximum length has been exceeded.”

In other words:

  • There must be a selection or promotion process to fill the position with a permanent contract. A selection process is the search for a new person; a promotion process is when the position is offered to someone already on the staff who moves up.
  • The contract lasts three months at most. If the collective agreement sets a shorter period, the agreement’s period applies.
  • Once that maximum has passed, another contract with the same purpose cannot be signed. In other words, the company cannot “renew” your substitution for that vacancy.

Lorena has been there for five months, and on top of that nobody has opened any process. Her contract breaks the law on two counts: it exceeds the three-month limit and it does not respond to a real selection process.

When the Contract Ends and Why There Is No Severance

One of the most frequent questions is “when does my contract end?” The answer depends on the use:

  • If you replace a person with the right to have their job held, the contract ends when that person returns or when their right to have the job held ends.
  • If you cover reduced working hours, it ends when the reason for that reduction disappears.
  • If you cover a vacancy during a selection or promotion process, it ends when the position is filled by the permanent employee or, at the latest, when the three months are up (or the shorter period in the collective agreement).

That is why a substitution contract usually does not have a fixed end date. Its end is not on the calendar, but in the reason.

Why You Do Not Receive Severance When It Ends

In most temporary contracts, when the contract ends, the worker receives severance of twelve days’ salary per year worked. The substitution contract is an exception. Article 49.1.c of the Workers’ Statute says so:

At the end of the contract, except in training contracts and the fixed-term contract due to substitution, the worker shall be entitled to receive severance

In other words, the law expressly excludes the substitution contract from that end-of-contract severance. When Cristina came back and Lorena’s first contract ended, Lorena was not entitled to those twelve days per year. It was not abuse by the company: it is what the law provides.

Be careful, this only applies when the contract really ends because of its reason. If the contract had already become permanent and the company ends it as if it were a simple “end of contract,” the situation changes completely, as we will see.

Your Rights While You Replace Someone: Same Pay and Conditions

Let’s go back to the collective agreement bonus that Lorena is not receiving. Many people think that, as a substitute or temporary worker, it is normal to earn less or have worse conditions. The law says the opposite. Article 15.6 states that “workers with temporary and fixed-term contracts shall have the same rights as workers with permanent contracts.”

This means that, while your substitution contract lasts, you have the same rights as the permanent staff: the same salary and the same bonuses that apply to your position, the same vacation and the same conditions.

If you find that you earn less than your permanent coworkers in the same position, you can claim the difference. In practice:

  • Compare your payslip with that of the permanent staff doing the same job and with what the collective agreement says.
  • Claim the difference from the company in writing.
  • Keep the deadline in mind: amounts are claimed within the year following the date on which they should have been paid. Whatever you do not claim in time, you lose.

Lorena can claim the collective agreement bonus for every month in which it was not paid, within that one-year period.

When You Become Permanent and What to Do

Here is the key to Lorena’s case. Article 15.4 of the Workers’ Statute is very clear:

Persons hired in breach of the provisions of this article shall acquire the status of permanent employees.

Acquiring the status of a permanent employee means that your contract becomes open-ended: it is no longer temporary and it no longer ends because someone returns or because a position is filled.

When does this happen in a substitution contract? When the rules we have seen are not met. For example:

  • The contract does not state the name of the replaced worker or the reason for the substitution.
  • The handover before the absence exceeds fifteen days or the time strictly necessary.
  • The coverage of a vacancy lasts more than three months (or longer than the period in the collective agreement), or another contract with the same purpose is signed afterwards.
  • The company uses the “substitution” label without there really being an absent worker with the right to have their job held, reduced working hours or a selection or promotion process.

In addition, if the reason has already disappeared (the replaced worker has returned or has lost their right to have the job held) and you keep working without a valid new contract, you can claim that your contract be considered permanent.

An important nuance: there is no magic number of months after which someone replacing another worker automatically becomes permanent. If you replace a person on long-term temporary incapacity or on a leave of absence with job protection, your contract can last a long time and still be valid, as long as the reason still exists. What matters is whether the reason exists and whether the contract follows the rules. The three-month limit applies only to covering vacancies. If you have been chaining substitutions for years, you should also read our article on abuse of temporary contracts in Spain and how to claim permanent status.

What to Do, Step by Step

If you have a substitution contract, this is what you should do:

  • Review your contract. Check that it states the name of the person you are replacing (or the vacant position you are covering) and the reason for the substitution.
  • Keep the communications. Save the emails, messages or letters about the replaced worker’s return or about the selection process. If the company says it is looking for someone, ask it to confirm this in writing.
  • Compare your payslip with that of your permanent coworkers in the same position and claim the difference in writing.
  • If the company tells you that your contract is ending and you believe there was no valid reason (because the contract was already permanent), act quickly: that end of contract is challenged as a dismissal, and the deadline to do so is twenty working days.

Twenty working days go by very quickly. If you receive an end-of-contract letter and have doubts, do not wait. In the employment law practice area, Fernanda Vargas, employment lawyer in Madrid, reviews your contracts, your payslip and the company’s letter, and tells you whether you can claim permanent status and the amounts you are owed.

How Lorena’s Case Is Resolved

Lorena’s first contract was correct. It identified the replaced worker (Cristina) and the reason (her birth leave), the handover lasted ten days, less than the fifteen the law allows, and it ended when Cristina returned. When it ended she was not entitled to severance, because the substitution contract is excluded from end-of-contract severance.

The second contract does not comply with the law. Covering a vacancy during a selection process cannot last more than three months (or less if the collective agreement says so), and Lorena has been there for five without any process existing. That is why she has acquired the status of a permanent employee.

In addition, while she works she has the same rights as the permanent staff, so she can claim the collective agreement bonus she is not being paid. And if the company tells her that the contract is ending, she must challenge it as a dismissal within twenty working days.

Summary: The Three Uses of the Substitution Contract

UseRequirements and limitsWhen it ends
Replacing a person with the right to have their job held (birth leave, temporary incapacity, leave of absence with job protection)The contract must state the name of the replaced worker and the reason. It may start before the absence, only for the time strictly necessary and for fifteen days at most.When the replaced worker returns or their right to have the job held ends.
Covering another worker’s reduced working hoursThe reduction must have a legal or collective agreement basis. The contract must state the name of the replaced worker and the reason.When the reason for the reduction of working hours disappears.
Covering a vacancy during a selection or promotion process for a permanent positionThree months at most (or less if the collective agreement says so). No other contract with the same purpose may be signed afterwards.When the position is filled or, at most, when the three months are up (or the collective agreement period).

In all three cases: the same rights as the permanent staff while the contract lasts, no end-of-contract severance when it ends, and permanent status if the rules are not met.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does My Substitution Contract Have an End Date?

Usually it does not have a fixed date, because its length depends on the reason. If you replace a person with the right to have their job held, it lasts until that person returns or until their right to have the job held ends. If you cover reduced working hours, it lasts as long as that reduction. The exception is covering a vacancy during a selection or promotion process: there is a maximum limit of three months, or less if your collective agreement says so.

If the Person I Am Replacing Does Not Come Back, What Happens to Me?

It depends on why they do not come back. If their right to have their job held ends, the reason for your contract disappears and the substitution contract ends. If, even so, the company keeps you working without signing a valid new contract, you can claim that your contract be considered permanent. Each case has its nuances, so it is worth reviewing it with Fernanda Vargas.

Do I Get Severance When It Ends?

No, if the contract really ends because of its reason. The law excludes the substitution contract from the twelve days per year of severance paid at the end of other temporary contracts. You may, however, be entitled to make a claim if your contract had already become permanent and the company ends it as if it were a simple end of contract: in that case it is challenged as a dismissal, within twenty working days.

Can They Hire Me to Cover a Vacancy for Six Months?

Not with a substitution contract. To cover a vacancy during a selection or promotion process, the maximum is three months (or the shorter period set by the collective agreement), and once it has passed another contract with the same purpose cannot be signed. If the company keeps you on longer, or there is no real selection process, you have acquired the status of a permanent employee.

Do I Get the Same Vacation and the Same Pay as My Coworkers?

Yes. While your substitution contract lasts you have the same rights as workers with a permanent contract, including vacation, salary and the bonuses that apply to your position. If you earn less than your permanent coworkers in the same position, you can claim the difference in writing, within the year following the date on which you should have been paid.

Do you have a substitution contract and are not sure whether it is valid, whether you are already permanent or whether you are being paid what you are owed? Write to Fernanda Vargas on WhatsApp or book an appointment on Calendly and we will review your case before the deadlines run out.

How we can help

Does this affect you? Fernanda Vargas reviews your case and explains your options. More about Employment lawyer in Madrid.